9 Dog Breeds That Prefer Freedom Over Commands

Some dogs are born to obey, while others are natural free spirits. If you’re a dog lover, you may have noticed that not all breeds are eager to follow commands. In fact, some dogs are highly independent and prefer to make their own decisions. These breeds aren’t disobedient out of defiance—they’re just strong-willed, intelligent, and often bred for tasks that required self-direction. In this post, we’ll explore 9 dog breeds that prefer freedom over commands. Whether you’re a prospective pet parent or just curious about canine behavior, understanding these breeds can help you better appreciate their unique personalities and needs. From the graceful Afghan Hound to the energetic Siberian Husky, each of these dogs has a mind of its own. So, if you’re ready to meet some lovable rebels, let’s dive into the most independent dog breeds that march to the beat of their own drum.

1. Afghan Hound

The Afghan Hound is a strikingly elegant dog with a silky coat and an aloof personality. Known for their independence, Afghan Hounds were originally bred for hunting in the mountains of Afghanistan. This background has instilled in them a strong sense of self-reliance, making them one of the least obedient breeds when it comes to training. While they are intelligent, they often choose to ignore commands, especially if they don’t see a benefit in obeying. These dogs require patience and positive reinforcement, as harsh training methods will only alienate them further. Afghan Hounds enjoy being pampered and admired but will often go off exploring on their own terms. They are not aggressive, just extremely dignified and aloof. For first-time dog owners, their unique temperament can be a challenge. However, experienced dog lovers who appreciate an elegant and independent spirit often find the Afghan Hound to be a deeply rewarding companion.

2. Basenji

The Basenji, often referred to as the “barkless dog,” is a small yet high-energy breed with a curious and independent nature. Originating from Central Africa, this breed was developed for hunting and is known for its cat-like behavior. Basenjis are incredibly intelligent, but they’re also notoriously stubborn. They tend to do things their own way and may completely ignore commands if they’re not in the mood. This trait doesn’t mean they aren’t trainable—it just requires creativity, consistency, and a lot of patience. The Basenji’s aloofness and love for exploration make them less interested in pleasing their owners compared to more obedient breeds. While they bond closely with their families, they value their autonomy and don’t respond well to repetitive training methods. Due to their strong prey drive and tendency to run off, secure fencing is essential. Despite their rebellious streak, Basenjis are affectionate and loyal once a bond is formed.

3. Chow Chow

Chow Chows are known for their lion-like mane and serious demeanor. Hailing from China, they were originally bred as guard dogs, which contributes to their strong-willed and independent personality. Unlike dogs that are eager to please, Chow Chows often behave more like cats—aloof, reserved, and highly selective with their affection. They are extremely intelligent but tend to use their smarts to assert their own will rather than follow commands. Training a Chow Chow requires early socialization and firm yet gentle leadership. They respond best to calm, confident owners who can establish trust without using force. These dogs often bond closely with one or two people and may be indifferent or even suspicious toward strangers. Because of their stoic nature and dominant tendencies, they’re not the best fit for households looking for a highly obedient, eager-to-please companion. However, with patience and mutual respect, a Chow Chow can be a loyal and protective friend.

4. Borzoi

The Borzoi, also known as the Russian Wolfhound, is a graceful and dignified sighthound originally bred to hunt wolves in the Russian countryside. Despite their aristocratic appearance, Borzois are free-spirited and prefer doing things their own way. They are quiet, gentle dogs, but obedience is not their strong suit. Borzois can be extremely stubborn when it comes to training—they may understand a command perfectly but simply choose not to follow it. Their independent thinking and strong prey drive can make them unreliable off-leash, especially in open areas. They need positive reinforcement and variety in training to stay engaged. Borzois dislike repetitive tasks and will often become bored or disinterested quickly. However, their calm demeanor and gentle personality make them wonderful companions in the right home. With consistent and respectful handling, they can develop into elegant and affectionate family pets, though they will always retain a touch of their noble aloofness.

5. Beagle

Beagles are cheerful, friendly dogs with an insatiable sense of smell and curiosity. Bred originally as scent hounds for tracking small game, their powerful noses often take precedence over their ears—meaning they’re more likely to follow a scent trail than your voice. While Beagles are intelligent, their independence and single-mindedness make them one of the less obedient breeds. Once on a trail, they can become completely oblivious to their surroundings, including commands to stop or come back. They also tend to be mischievous and stubborn, which can make training a challenge, especially for novice owners. Despite this, Beagles are loving, social dogs that thrive on companionship and activity. They require plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to keep their behavior in check. With consistency, patience, and food-based rewards, Beagles can learn commands—but expect them to push boundaries regularly. Their charm and happy nature often make up for their lack of reliability.

6. Bulldog

Bulldogs are iconic for their stocky build, wrinkled faces, and calm demeanor, but they’re also known for being incredibly stubborn. While they’re not hyper or mischievous like some other breeds on this list, Bulldogs have a very independent mindset. They may respond to a command—if they feel like it. Their laid-back attitude often masks a quiet determination to do things at their own pace, which can be mistaken for laziness or lack of intelligence. In truth, Bulldogs are smart but not particularly motivated by praise or even treats in some cases. Training a Bulldog requires consistency, patience, and sometimes creativity to keep them interested. They may be less driven to perform tricks or engage in obedience trials, but they make up for it with their loving, loyal nature. Bulldogs are excellent with children and make great family pets, provided owners understand and accept their willful personalities.

7. Dachshund

Dachshunds, also known as “wiener dogs,” are small in size but packed with personality. Bred for hunting badgers, these little dogs are fearless, curious, and notoriously independent. Their strong prey drive and bold nature often override obedience, making training a challenge. Dachshunds are clever but can be obstinate, particularly when asked to do something they don’t want to do. They respond best to short, fun training sessions and positive reinforcement, as harsh methods will cause them to shut down or become even more resistant. Their independence means they like to make their own decisions, especially when exploring or chasing scents. While they’re affectionate and devoted to their families, their stubborn streak can make them difficult for first-time dog owners. Socialization and early training are key to managing their spirited temperament. With the right approach, Dachshunds can be both entertaining and loving, even if they never become fully obedient.

8. Jack Russell Terrier

Jack Russell Terriers are small, energetic dogs with a big attitude. Bred for fox hunting, they possess strong instincts, high intelligence, and endless energy—all of which contribute to their reputation for being headstrong and difficult to train. While they are quick learners, Jack Russells tend to follow their own agenda unless training is made highly engaging and reward-driven. They often become bored with repetition and need constant mental and physical stimulation to stay focused. If not properly trained and exercised, they may resort to destructive behavior out of frustration. Their intense prey drive and confidence make them prone to chasing and ignoring recall commands, particularly outdoors. These dogs do best with experienced owners who can provide firm boundaries and consistent training. Despite their disobedient streak, Jack Russells are loyal, affectionate companions who thrive in active households where they have a job to do—or at least a daily adventure to burn off energy.

9. Siberian Husky

Siberian Huskies are beautiful, wolf-like dogs known for their stamina and independent spirit. Originally bred to pull sleds over long distances, Huskies are hardwired for endurance and autonomy. This makes them one of the most challenging breeds to train in terms of obedience. They are intelligent and quick learners, but they often choose to ignore commands, especially if they sense no immediate benefit. Huskies are notorious escape artists and can be highly destructive if bored or under-exercised. Consistent training and a secure environment are essential. Their free-spirited nature means they often get along well with other dogs but may not form the same level of attachment or eagerness to please that other breeds exhibit. Positive reinforcement and variety in training are key to keeping a Husky engaged. For active and experienced dog owners who understand the breed’s quirks, Huskies can be loyal and adventurous companions full of personality and charm.

Bottom Line

Obedience isn’t the only measure of a dog’s worth. The breeds featured in this list are intelligent, loyal, and loving—but they also value independence and may not always respond to commands. While they might not win obedience competitions, they’ll capture your heart with their strong personalities and free-spirited charm. These dogs are best suited for experienced owners who understand their unique traits and are willing to work with them, not against them. If you’re looking for a challenge and a loyal companion who keeps life interesting, one of these independent breeds might be your perfect match.

FAQs